Make the Sweet Dehydrated Orange Slice Garnish (Optional)
Preheat the oven to 200°F. Wash and dry the blood oranges and naval oranges, then cut into very thin slices (as thin as possible). Lay them flat on a baking sheet with parchment paper.
In a small bowl, mix the spices and sugar and then sprinkle evenly over the orange slices. Dry in the oven at 200°F for 2 ½ to 3 hours. If your orange slices are thick, they will take longer.
After removing them from the oven, add more spices and/or sugar, if desired. Store in an airtight bag or container.
Make the Wine
Place all ingredients except the oranges into a pot over medium-low heat. Stir the mixture until the brown sugar has mostly dissolved.
Using a peeler, peel half of one orange. Avoid peeling the pith (the white layer between the outer zest and the fruit) as it is very bitter. Juice the oranges and add the juice to the pot along with the orange peel. Warm the mixture until it just starts to steam, reduce the heat and allow to gently simmer for around 30 mins.
Use a ladle to serve, avoiding the spices and peel (or use a small strainer). Garnish with a dehydrated orange, star anise and cinnamon sticks.
Notes
If you prefer a less sweet version, you can omit the brown sugar in this recipe.Substitutions:
Spices: Any number of spices can be used or altered according to your taste. Peppercorns, whole nutmeg and black cardamom are just a few that can be substituted freely.
Brown Sugar: You can make 1 for 1 substitutions with molasses, white sugar, honey or any sweetener if desired.
Storage:
How to store leftover mulled wine: Just put it in an airtight container, let it cool to room temperature, then keep it in the refrigerator for up to 5 days.
How to reheat leftover mulled wine: Just add it to a pot and reheat on medium-low heat until warm.
Can you freeze leftover mulled wine? Although this seems strange, it is possible to do this without much flavor degradation. You can also freeze them in ice cube trays and you have mulled wine ice cubes for drinks!
Top Tips:
Use whole spices in the mulled wine - NOT GROUND SPICES. Not only does the addition of whole spices look pretty in the pot, but they also allow the flavors of the spices to infuse the wine without changing the consistency in the finished mulled wine. The last thing you want is a mouthful of ground spices when drinking a tasty mulled wine.